Sunday, December 30, 2001 By Robin Wallace
As this holiday season comes to a close,
so too does one of the newest traditions Americans have
come to expect this time of year: reports of school officials,
town councils and company presidents outlawing Christmas in
the interest of cultural sensitivity.
But as the stories of dismantled nativity
scenes, banned Santa Clauses and bans on wishing
shoppers a "Merry Christmas" grow more outlandish, so does the
logic and reasoning behind these decisions.
In the name of "tolerance" for all
cultures, the community leaders and educators issuing these
edicts are enforcing an intolerance of any culture. Instead of
encouraging Americans to celebrate their rich cultural
diversity, those banning cultural expression are asking
us to deny that diversity.
If we were truly concerned
with multiculturalism, we would erect
a display in the town plaza or the elementary school
lobby that incorporated the symbols of all holidays celebrated
at this time of year. But instead of striving for an
inclusiveness that would truly promote acceptance and
understanding, we recognize our diversity by adhering to an
exclusiveness that only keeps us suspicious and ignorant.
In any other year, this all could be
chalked up to the frustrating and misguided inanity of
political correctness run amok. But this holiday season, the
"culture war" was no longer a metaphor. The United States is
fighting a real war that is almost entirely about the clash of
cultures and religion, the most virulent strain of intolerance
and hatred and the most violent rejection of diversity.
With the squabbling over holiday expression
in our public spaces coming to a close for this season, it may
be worth it to keep in mind as we head into a new, and
hopefully less awful and tragic year, that the terrorists who
leveled the World Trade Center, tore a hole in the Pentagon
and crashed a plane into a field in Pennsylvania were
targeting Americans, period. Their hate did not make
distinctions between the rich and the poor, the immigrant and
the native born, the bond trader and the fireman, the
religious and the atheist.
They were not targeting or sparing, for
that matter Italian-Americans or African-Americans, Chinese
immigrants or Puerto Ricans. They didn't choose among
Christians or Jews. They showed no mercy or pity for
Arab-Americans or fellow Muslims.
The terrorists who hate Americans and
America don't draw the same distinctions or divisions between
Americans that we do among ourselves. They were, and are,
after all of us.
There may be no greater symbol of our
democracy than America's diversity, the ideal if not always
the reality of the equal and peaceful co-existence of so
many people of different colors, races, nations, and faiths,
and the inviolable rights of those people to express those
differences and celebrate those heritages. Every time a school
official or a town council shuts down a holiday expression,
they distort and infringe upon the very essence of what it
means to be an American.
We now have troops fighting and dying
overseas to defend that culture, and thousands of families
without their loved ones this Christmas because, by
exemplifying the very best this culture had to offer, they
became a target. Invoking "what it means to be an American"
may ring of unsophisticated jingoism, but more than any other
nation America is symbolized primarily by its people.
One of the many lessons we have learned
since Sept. 11 is that beyond our borders, to those who seek
to emulate us as well as to those who would destroy us, we are
all simply Americans. Collectively and individually we
represent an American culture that, if we did not know it
already, we now know with absolute certainty, means something
awesome and mighty to the rest of the world. |